PHAM QUANG HAM*
* Dr. Pham Quang Ham is the Head of the
Department of Industry
at the Development Strategy Institute,
Ministry of Planning and Investment, Hanoi.
I. INDUSTRIAL RESTRUCTURING IN RECENT
YEARS.
As the industrial sector assumes a crucial
position in the process of economic development, the results
generated by the political line of renovation of the industrial
sector are highly important. In particular:
1. In spite of various difficulties, many advances the industrial
sector created preconditions for its further development.
During the years 1990-1994 the average annual growth rate of
industrial production was 12.3 percent (Figure 1). This gain lead to
a shift in the economic structure as the proportion of industry and
construction in GDP increased from 22.6 percent in 1990 to 29.6
percent in 1994 (Figure 2). The technological and technical
composition of different economic sectors and branches has also
recorded significant changes, though not as profound as the shift in
composition of GDP. Technological innovation has become a pressing
requirement for the national economy. Some advanced technologies have
been introduced and applied, such as information technology and
electronics.
Some economically meaningful industrial products have shown high
growth rates. Electricity, crude oil, cement, fertilizers, as well as
some exportable consumer goods and products of food industry, are
included among these.
The industrial enterprises and production establishments have paid
more attention to the quality and design of their products. They have
shown more initiative and flexibility in adjusting to the market
requirements. This is just due to the fact that the previous support
in form of state subsidies was abolished and all the businesses then
faced a more competitive environment.
2. In the industrial sector, various economic components have been
assisted to develop in conformity with the interests of the nation
and of the businessmen themselves.
The state-owned industrial enterprises have been rearranged and
consolidated in the spirit of rationalization and effectiveness so
that the public sector would in fact maintain a leading role in the
development process. Many enterprises that found themselves in
trouble in the first months under the new management mechanism have
now "risen up" and recorded better results.
The non-state industries have been promoted, particularly in
processing agro-products, and in producing consumer goods and
handicrafts.
By the end of 1994, in the processing industry alone, there were
already 8,866 establishments licensed. Among them, 58 percent were
registered as private enterprises and another 17 percent as companies
of limited liability. Additionally, as for the small and handicraft
industries, there were 5,287 cooperatives and more than 450,000
private households involved in production activities.
Figure 1: AVERAGE ANNUAL GROWTH RATE OF
INDUSTRIES
IN 1990 - 1994 (%, IN PRICE OF 1994)
Figure 2: STRUCTURE OF INDUSTRY IN 1994
(%)
3. External economic relations have
further developed. Foreign direct investments (FDI) in general and
investments into the industrial sector in particular have shown a
rapidly increasing trend.
In recent years, the export volume has recorded an average annual
growth rate of 20 percent of which the industrial sector shares an
important part, accounting for over 50 percent of the country's total
export volume.
The registered capital of FDI projects so far licensed accounts for
approximately 18 billion USD. If projects in the field of oil and gas
are included the industrial sector share would account for more than
60 percent of FDI. The joint-ventures constitute the principal form,
accounting for more than 65 percent of FDI projects. The investment
activities are now territorially distributed through more
regions.
Six export-processing zones (EPZ) have been granted licenses. Some of
them have already been put into operation, absorbing several
industrial enterprises, whose products are destined for export. An
integral process of elaborating master plans for industrial estates
is just being undertaken, conformably with the infrastructure
facilities development and urbanization plans. Some industrial
estates are now already under construction. These measures aim at
generating a favorable environment to attract investments, both
domestic and foreign, into the industrial sector, particularly into
export-oriented industrial branches.
There are several problems to be addressed in industrial
development:
a/ The industrial sector still has only small productive capacity,
incapable of generating by itself the necessary resources for
re-investment. It's ability to re-equip the national economy, in
particular, its ability to support agricultural production and the
rural economy, still appears to be negligible.
The manpower engaged in the industrial sector accounts for only about
11 percent of the total labour force, whilst agriculture still
absorbs the largest part of the labor force, i.e., more than 72
percent.
b/ The industrial structure has slowly changed. In the recent period,
the growth in industrial production has principally resulted from
mining, while the proportion of growth from manufacturing branches
has been small. Industrial products for export mainly composed raw
materials with little preliminary processing. Machinery engineering
and electronics were only at the beginning of their evolution and
primarily consist of assembling in the CKD mode. The development
scope of industrial branches serving agriculture, both for its input
and for its output, was still limited: the value of processed
agro-products accounted only for about 30 percent, and the level of
mechanization in agricultural production was still low.
c/ Though the economy began to generate its internal capital
resources, such resources are still small and scattered, hence the
investments for development still depend on various external sources.
In this context, for the immediate years, there still remain
difficulties that hinder an active and innovative restructuring of
the industrial sector.
d/ The low technological level of manufacturing usually implies high
norms of material spending in production units, low productivity of
labor, and low quality of manufactured products. This fact requires
large investments in order to undertake technological innovation to
improve the competitiveness of industrial products on the market; and
at the same time, to generate close linkages between different
economic sectors, especially between industry and agriculture aimed
at positively restructuring the agricultural production and rural
economy in the direction of industrialization and modernization.
e/ The infrastructure is still weak, which inhibits investment, both
domestic and FDI, for industrial development.
g/ There are still some state-owned industrial establishments that
have not successfully adapted themselves to the new mechanism. They
still show poor efficiency. The development of non-state industrial
sector still seems to be sluggish.
II. INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT ORIENTATIONS TO
THE YEAR 2000.
The long run objective is to develop a
relatively comprehensive industrial sector, in order to transform
Vietnam from a backward agriculture-based country into an
industrialized one. It is hoped to obtain this objective within a
period of two decades. This requires creation of an environment in
which the industrial sector may develop at a high rate during
successive years, so that the national economy can be rapidly
restructured in the sense of industrialization and modernization, and
early integration into the regional and world economy.
It is important to use the five-year period 1996-2000 to generate
preconditions for stronger development in the next decades. During
1996-2000, conditions should be created for the industrial sector to
develop at an annual rate of 14-15 percent; meanwhile to keep this
rate or to promote a higher rate for after the year 2000.
In this regard, the value added of the industrial sector is expected
to reach a figure of 34-35 percent of GDP by the year 2000, and
hence, the share of industrial production in GDP will exceed that of
the agriculture.
Efforts should be made to advance the process of technical
innovation, thus improving the competitiveness of the existing
industrial establishments. At the same time, it is desirable to
strongly attract domestic and foreign investments to develop the
processing and manufacturing industries and natural resources,
following a clear orientation to exports or industrial development.
Priorities will be given to:
a/ The food processing industry, which is to both satisfy the
domestic demand and to meet quality requirements for export
promotions. The scales of production and levels of technology should
correspond to each locality and each product so that a majority of
agro-forestry-fisheries products would be processed, first of all,
rice, rubber, coffee, tea, sea products, sugar cane, vegetables and
fruits, as well as meats of different kinds.
b/ The consumer goods industry, which is to respond to the internal
demand, in substituting for imports, and to effectively serve
exports, making full use of comparative advantages in manpower. These
branches are principally textiles, garments, leather processing,
shoes producing, building materials, fine-arts articles, toys, and
household appliances.
c/ Further investigation, exploration, and exploitation of oil and
gas. Constructing of a complex for collecting and transporting
off-shore gas to borders will be completed. Making an effective use
of gas for producing electric power, liquidized gas, nitrogenous
fertilizer and to create favorable conditions to early develop an
industrial branch producing gas-based chemicals will also be a
priority. Construction of the first refinery should be accelerated,
and preparations for successive construction of the second refinery
should be made.
Forms of cooperation and joint-ventures will be broadened in order to
improve the capabilities of the national oil-gas industry in
investigation, exploitation, processing and services provision.
d/ It is desirable to reorganize and further consolidate the
mechanical engineering industry so that it will become a key branch,
capable of providing other production branches with a major part of
necessary equipment and instruments.
Domestic production and importation should be combined to assure the
supply of equipment, firstly equipment for the agro-processing
industry, transport means, and spare parts. Efforts should be made to
develop branches for building and repairing marine vessels,
assembling and manufacturing cars, motorbikes, electrical appliances,
etc.
e/ The electronics and information technology industry should be
promoted. For the immediate time it should produce selected
accessories, and assemble equipment for civil and industrial
electronics, informatics, and communications equipment. Steps should
be taken to widen computer-based services, especially to develop
application software packages for different domains of scientific
research, production, and daily life.
g/ Bases of heavy industry should be built in targeted fields, where
there are urgent requirements and where there exist adequate
conditions on capital, technology, and consumption markets in the
sense that the establishments in question would rapidly show their
effectiveness and positive influence.
h/ Strong development of the export-led industries is desirable,
particularly manufacturing branches, thus facilitating a fast,
sustainable, and effective growth of the national economy. At the
same time, it is indispensable to adequately stress manufacturing for
the internal market. The Government should only introduce measures of
protection that have a suitable degree of protection and a time limit
so that prospective domestic industrial products gradually improve
their competitiveness.
There are different policies and measures should be taken in order to
encourage the industrial development. Some important policies are as
follow:
* To bring into full play combined forces of different economic
components to promote the industrial development. To renovate and
further consolidate state-owned enterprises in the direction of
improving their efficiency so that they could properly deserve their
leading role. To create favorable conditions and a legal environment
in order that the private sector would feel assured to make long term
investments in productive enterprises. To encourage the private
capitalist economic component in making its investments into
production activities. It is necessary to properly protect the
legitimate property ownership and private interests. To widen forms
of cooperation, integration and joint venturing between the public
economic sector and the private sector, both domestic and
foreign.
* Small-and medium-scale enterprises have played and will still play
an increasingly important role in the national economic development.
With their inherent advantages, enterprises of this kind are capable
of resolving numerous problems that large-scale enterprises are
hardly able to do, such as generating employment opportunities,
promoting rural development, justice and stability, and the like. In
this regard, the Government should adopt proper and effective
supporting policy measures.
* It is crucial to upgrade, rehabilitate and newly construct (with
suitable prioritization) the economic infrastructure, first tackling
the most congested and weakest links that still impede the
development course.
To rehabilitate and consolidate existing industrial estates in terms
of infrastructure facilities and production technology. Resources
should be mobilized to build several industrial estates, allocated
largely to the different focal economic regions. The development of
industrial estates should be kept in parallel with the development of
infrastructure facilities and rational urbanization.
III. GEOGRAPHICAL ALLOCATION OF INDUSTRIAL
PRODUCTION
One of the most important issues is to pay special attention to anequal development of different territorial regions. The objective of
so allocating industrial production is to step-by-step bring about
such equal development.
1. Concerning the currently existing
industrial estates and complexes:
Based on the overall master plan, it is
necessary to examine possibilities of expansion and/or improvement
following the directions listed below:
- In case of complexes which are situated deeply in the urban
interior, next to populous residential quarters, there will be mainly
in-depth investments, aimed at technological upgrading and
modernization, as well as resolving the problem of environmental
pollution. It is necessary to move or even demolish those plants that
prove to be too old, or to cause heavily poisonous pollution.
- As for the complexes which are placed far from the urban centers
and have adequate land area, it is supposed to improve the technical
infrastructure, to revise the master plan in terms to use their land
more intensively, and setting out their investment direction so to
effectively attract investments.
In any case, it is indispensable to attach a master plan of
industrial estates and complexes to that of urbanization
development.
2. Concerning new industrial estates:
Elaboration of the nation-wide overall
master plan is required in order to specify alternatives for
allocation of industrial production, while attaching a master plan of
industrial development to these of infrastructure and urbanization
development. Locations with better conditions for earlier development
(during next 10-15 years) should be chosen in order to lay the
foundation for more detailed programming. In these locations some
integral conditions should be guaranteed, namely, electricity and
water supply, drainage, and transportation.
In the immediate time, to promote a rapid general economic
development, stress should be given to areas which have more
convenient background in terms of infrastructure, material supply,
consumption market, and which prove to be more attractive for
investors, both domestic and foreign. These areas are currently the 3
focal economic zones: the triangle of Hanoi - Haiphong - Halong; the
triangle of Ho Chi Minh City - Bien Hoa - Vung Tau; and the central
region of Lien Chieu - Dung Quat.
As for non-focal zones, it is reasonable to consolidate the currently
available industrial production units and complexes under the form of
in-depth investments, technological rehabilitation and innovation.
New industrial complexes could be established for those localities
that have favorable conditions.
As for areas surrounding the focal zones, it is required to establish
relations of cooperation, integration, and interaction with the
latter within their process of industrial development. It is possible
to create a kind of "supportive" industrial production, "satellite or
peripheral" industrial complexes, in absorbing production units
released from large cities.
As for mountainous regions, the Central highlands are now still
facing numerous infrastructure difficulties, that obviously hinder
their industrial development. In this regard, special attention
should be paid to the problem of infrastructure facilities,
particularly roads, hence facilitating an eventual growth of
industrial production and complexes in the future. For the immediate
time, it is desirable to develop small-scale industrial formations in
different towns and townships; principally processing industries
linked with agriculture and forestry, and to construct small-size
hydro-power stations.
It is also necessary to prepare terrain and location for important
projects, such as refineries, petro-chemical complexes, large-scale
metallurgy, etc. Due to their requirements for large-scale transport,
such projects should be better located near to sea-ports. In
addition, they require large land areas and appropriate settlement of
environmental problems.
To sum up, the question of geographical allocation of industrial
production for the coming years, in our opinion, should be handled
with a clear awareness of targets and priorities, in view of creating
a favorable environment to attract financial sources for the
industrial development. It is highly desirable to attentively develop
small-and medium-scale industries, particularly processing
industries, linked with sources of raw materials from the
agricultural sectors, so that the inter-regional gaps in development
will be gradually reduced.